|
There is a
memorial to those who died at the Arlington
National
Cemetery, which includes the ship's main mast. There is also a memorial,
consisting of the shield and scrollwork from the bow of the ship, in Bangor,
Maine. The fore mast of the
Maine
is located at the
United States
Naval
Academy
at Annapolis,
Maryland. There is a traditional in-joke among midshipmen at the Academy that the
Maine, with its main mast in Eastern Virginia and its fore mast in
Central Maryland, is the longest ship in the Navy.
Causes of
the sinking
The facts
Because of
the uproar the sinking of the
Maine
caused in the United States, President McKinley demanded an investigation into the cause of the
explosions immediately. A U.S. Naval Court of Inquiry arrived in Havana
and began its investigation. Survivors and eyewitnesses testified for the
court, and several navy divers explored the sunken ship, hoping to find
clues as to what may have caused the disaster. All parties involved
concluded without a doubt that the explosion of the forward six-inch
ammunition magazines had caused the sinking. Why those magazines had
exploded, no one could determine conclusively, and doubt remains as to the
exact cause to this day. There have been four major investigations into
the sinking since 1898. From the four inquiries, two theories have
emerged: one, that a mine in Havana
Harbor
had exploded underneath the battleship, causing the explosion of the
magazines; and two, that spontaneous combustion of the coal in bunker A16
created a fire that detonated the nearby magazines.
External
mine theory
The theory
that a mine, allegedly planted by the Spanish as a way to deter the
efforts of the United States to take Cuba, is the assumption that most
Americans came to immediately after the sinking, because it provided the
stimulus for war that the U.S. had been quietly seeking. However, all
parties now recognize that even if a mine had been involved in the sinking
of the
Maine, the Spanish government had nothing to do with it, because it would have
been unreasonable for
Spain
to provoke an attack and bring itself into a war where it would most
certainly lose its last precious colonies in the
Western Hemisphere. Rather, the mine could have been placed to defend the harbor and
unintentionally drifted to where the
Maine
was moored. Alternatively, the mine could have been used by Cuban rebels
in the hopes that the attack on the
Maine
would be blamed on the Spanish and so trigger a war between the
United States
and Spain.
Some key
evidence indicates that the cause of the sinking was an external mine.
First, many of the witnesses stated that they heard two distinct
explosions several seconds apart. If anything else besides a mine had
triggered the magazine explosion, then witnesses would have only heard one
blast, because the only explosion would have been of the magazines. The
only reason that two explosions would have been heard is if something
besides the magazine had exploded, such as a mine. A coal bunker fire
would have caused the magazines to explode, but it would not have caused
an additional explosion.
Another
piece of evidence of an external mine was the observations of divers who
examined the bottom plates of the Maine. These bottom plates were all
bent inward. If an internal explosion had
occurred, the bottom plates would have been bent outward, away from the
explosion. An external blast would have blown the plates inward,
consistent with the evidence. A large hole in the side of the hull was
also observed with the edges bent inward. On the floor of Havana
Harbor,
a large hole was noticed, presumably from the explosion, although it
could be argued that an explosion of that magnitude would have put a hole
in the harbor floor, regardless of whether the explosion was internal or
external.
Two problems
with the external mine theory remain. One is the absence of dead fish in Havana
Harbor
the next day. Assuming that fish lived in the polluted waters of the
harbor, many of them should have been killed if a mine exploded in their
habitat, but no one reported seeing any floating in the harbor. Also, no
one reported seeing a geyser of water thrown up during the explosion, a
common sight when mines explode underwater. Many feel that if an external
explosion had occurred, it most certainly would have been coupled with a
geyser.
|
|